Sunday, 26 July 2015

Is education in Singapore the Great Leveller of Society? SingaporeEducation, Elite Schools and Social Mobility.



How do average students from HDB flats enter elite schools?

We hear stories of students who do well in school, and achieve stellar success in the current education system. How do they do it?

How did these students achieve stellar success? Is it by their own effort or through outside assistance?

The current tuition market is worth an astounding S$1.1 Billion as of 2013, and it used to be worth S$700,000 odd in the 1990s. According to the most recent household expenditure survey conducted by the Singapore Statistics Bureau, average household expenditure on tuition (including extra curricular enrichment classes of all kinds) is increasing year on year according to the Singapore Statistics Bureau, with no signs of abating. The quick and dirty calculation over 25 years puts the average growth of the industry at an astounding $43 million per year! 

The average Singaporean household spends S$100 per household on Tuition. The report on local expenditures do not contain the highest value nor the lowest value in their breakdown of the figures. But Suffice to say that wealthy families spend disproportionately more on extracurricular classes than families with lower disposable incomes.

What this means is that the public school system is presently grossly insufficient to meet the demands of most households for education. There is a huge need gap in society which is filled by the Tuition market. There can be two reasons 1) parents expectations are rising or 2) the system is too difficult for most students to master. Having tutored kids in the psle range 240 and under (these are really smart kids).

I'm not pointing to gaps in the school system so that standards can be lowered. I am advocating that more support for children should be rendered for them to master the vocabulary and reading skills which are presently woefully insufficient. University level logic, argument, vocabulary and reading skills are imposed upon kids who are not prepared to read at this grade and level.

The system is ridiculously difficult. Almost with no exception, all my students struggle master the current system's requirements on vocabulary and basic comprehensive tasks, not to talk about deep analytical skills. Why is the system so ridiculously difficult? I will answer that question in my next article post.

"The current system seems to be held together by home tutors" says not one, but two of the parents of teens I tutor. I have students who have tuition for 7 subjects, many of whom have tuition for 3 subjects for their O levels. Coming from both sides of the system as a secondary school teacher and as a home tutor I can see why. An interesting thought came from a parent of a student a tutored. Parent runs a trading business and aspires for her daughter go to an elite school. Daughter scored 240 and ended up in a good neighbourhood school instead. This parent went to ask her peers - other parents with kids in RI/RGS what did you do to cause your kids to excel? The answer? - Tuition! "Start from a young age, they said" She regrets not sending her only daughter to tuition classes when she was younger.

Singapore Education : "The great Leveller"?

My question is this, wasn't education supposed to be the great leveller of society? The great opportunity that causes social mobility, in theory the catalyst which causes and enables children from poor families to earn more income providing a flat playing field? Isn't public education supposed to be this open, generous opportunity to excel for both rich and poor families?

Ho Kwon Ping had interesting insights into Education and social mobility in Singapore. In his report on education in Singapore he points to the following facts:


  • Only 40 per cent of pupils in the most prestigious primary schools live in HDB flats, in contrast with 80 per cent of all primary school pupils residing in HDB flats. Which means 60% of puplis in the most prestigious primary schools live in private properties, when they only make up 20% of the population - a gross over-representation, to say the least.

  • More than half of Public Service Commission (PSC) scholarship recipients live in private housing, compared with only 15 per cent of the general population. More than 50% of the distribution of the awards of the PSC scholarship (the most prestigious scholarship in the government for public service) goes to private estate dwelling families, though they comprise only 20% of the population of Singapore. 

  • And 60 per cent of PSC scholarship holders come from only two schools - Raffles and Hwa Chong. The two best secondary schools in academic rankings in Singapore, Hwa Chong and Raffles produce more than 60% of PSC scholars.

  • 63% of university-educated fathers, 37 % of those with secondary school qualifications, and only 12% primary education or less, had children with university degrees. (The odds of a family to produce university graduates decreases exponentially if the lower qualified the father of a household is.)

This is the interpretation- the more money you have, the more you can invest in outside help to help your kids to excel in a system which is leaving more and more students behind, in order to make things more difficult academically. The main purpose? To spot the cream of the crop and award these people with limited university places. Wealth will stay in the hands of the educated rich while remaining elusive for the uneducated poor.

The reasons why the poor remain poor, from an education perspective - "The 30 million word gap"

An American Study put recorders on rich and poor families children and they discovered that the children of poor families heard up to 30 million words fewer than those who came from privileged and wealthy families. This finding has been cited by Psychology today, Atlantic newspaper, Hillary Clinton has started an NGO in order to close this word gap in order to help poor parents to begin to read and talk to their kids more in order to close this word gap.

I think they should expand the vocabularies of poor parents in order for there to be a trickle down effect to kids. Amongst the research findings which you will find if you google "30 million word gap" is the poor families tend to underestimate the importance of speaking to babies under the age of 3 years old, when Brain Neuron development is at its peak growth level, where much of baby's brain matter is being formed at the the less than three year old age group.

The NPR article is found here,

http://www.npr.org/2013/12/29/257922222/closing-the-word-gap-between-rich-and-poor

With the Psychology Today article here,

https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-athletes-way/201402/tackling-the-vocabulary-gap-between-rich-and-poor-children

What kind of Singapore do we want? Do we value social mobility and equality like we say we do? If we do, then why do we continue to perpetuate a education system which does the opposite of providing equal opportunity?

Friday, 24 July 2015

Introverts, Innovation and the case for customised mentor-based education part 1




Conformity and its pressures in Singapore

In no time since the dawn of civilisation has conformity been such a powerful force in society - in hunter gathering times, one could forage and work as one wished. Nomadic societies experience great freedom to pursue artistic and poetics pursuit such as music, arts, poetry and a variety of other activities which cause the thriving of the soul. by and large, Hunter gathering societies had the luxury of time to experiencing the beauty of nature, and the pursuit of the spiritual meaning through culture, music and ritual. E.g. American Indian societies.

(See The Advent of Agriculture - crash course history by John Green https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yocja_N5s1I)

Early America right after its founding by the pilgrims was educated in home-school fashion, with governors acting as personal tutors and reading ability by the time a child reached 16 was at today's college level. People achieved much in short time, by the time one turned 18, it was normative to become a lawyer.

Now we have children being born into schools which mainly emphasise control. With the schooling experience comes a great pressure to conform to societal pressures. Public school students are cruel in picking on teenagers who do not fit the popular mould.

Strongly introverted and independent types

1) are likely not to thrive socially in such settings
2) are prone to experience strong pressures to conform to society's expectations of them.

Singapore is a place where we place a strong premium on conformity, whether we admit it or not. Public school with its teacher to student ratios of 1:40 are places where no independence is tolerated, more for practical reasons than for any reasons of ideology.

Parents place huge expectations on teens to succeed, everyone is aware of what is at stake - a future of financial independence. Success is couched therefore in terms of conformity to a set patten of thinking, to a correct method of solving problems, to a rigid way of thinking which is inflexible.

Public education is inflexible in its approach. 

Ken Robinson points to the classification of students by age as a problem. He says one student has more in common than another if their learning styles match (kinesthetic learners will do more dance or sports melded with sports sciences and link these to their academic subjects biology is especially relevant and so is physics and motion).

Grouping students according to their passion makes more sense - if they love the aesthetics or love the sciences. It makes more sense for a customised education which fast tracks students in the subjects they excel in because of individual variation, learning styles, abilities and interest, than to classify them merely because of age.

The current system assumes that by the time a child is of a certain age, all his strengths will 'level up' in uniform fashion. As a teacher, I would have to say that this assumption is absurd!

As a public school teacher, the ratio of 1:40 leads to this inevitable outcome - the demand that students all see things the same, think the same, analyse the same and come to the same conclusions. I contend that this tendency is downright harmful to innovative and creative thinking. And forces deep individual thinkers to forsake their unique thoughts, feelings and perspectives to meet the 'educational standard' set by the ministry of education. I am not criticising the ministry for its work, but I am merely pointing out the inevitable outcomes which stem from the structures in place.

Being comfortable in your own skin

I am making an argument for introverts who do not seem to thrive in the current school system. Extroverts relate to others naturally and have a natural physiology which make social activities naturally rewarding.

Extroverts in the public school and in life are likely to be the ones who hold social capital - respect, social emotional skills and intelligence. Reference to Susan Cain's book, Quiet seems appropriate as reference to support my point. Conversely they are likely also to become the bullies of public school.

Introverts make up 50% of the worlds population, yet disproportionately society favours extroverts. Susan Cain Says,

Introverts, innovation and society

“The place of introverts in our culture today is very similar to where women were in the 1950s and early 1960s,” she said. “Half the population was discounted for something that went to the core of who they were. And it was also a population on the verge of coming into its own, like what’s happening with introverts now. We’re at the cusp of a real sea change in the way we understand this personality type.”

Yet introverts like Steve Jobs and Bill Gates are responsible for the kinds of innovation which shape and change society in an exponential way. It is my firm opinion that something has to change in the public school system to enhance individual mentoring to cause society to propel itself to the next level by encouraging a customised and tailor-made education run by mentor-teachers which causes a shift in society towards innovation, creativity and invention.

For innovation and creativity to thrive in society today, we must be more ready to accept multiple perspectives, to push unique thinking to its limits, satisfy our students curiosity for learning (which is not possible at a 1:40 ratio) and drive innovative and creative thinking for society to get to the next level.

The question which merits serious consideration is this - would a Bill Gates, a Steve Jobs, a Mark Zuckerberg thrive today in the Singapore public school system? If not, then we are going in the wrong direction.